RationalWiki's 2019 Fundraiser

There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff – we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.

If everyone who saw this today donated $5, we would meet our goal for 2019.

Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with PayPal Logo.png!

Information icon.svg The 2018 moderator election has started! We are electing 6 moderators and 2 alternatives to serve in 2019. Nominate users here and read their campaign slogans here!

Teetotalism

From RationalWiki
(Redirected from Temperance)
Jump to: navigation, search

Teetotalitarianism is complete abstinence from the consumption of alcoholic beverages. It is often used synonymously with temperance, but that is a change from the original meaning of temperance which is to temper (control or limit) one's use of alcohol: in other words, moderation. Eventually temperance came to mean the same thing as teetotalism, which means to never touch even a drop of alcohol,[1] an extreme position which you might recognize as the opposite of moderation (i.e. temperance). Like most extremist positions, it tends to be a sign of someone untrustworthy—note that teetotalism should not be confused with the case of recovering alcoholics or people who just choose not to drink but don't harangue others about it.

The idea that a person's diet can (or should) be completely completely free of alcohol is a bit loony since all leavened breads[2] and many fruits (especially juices) contain small amounts of alcohol.[3] People didn't know this at the time that teetotalism first became popular (pre-20th century) because analytic chemistry was not so accurate back then. Basically, carbohydrates + water + ambient yeast + time is going to produce at least some small amount of alcohol. A person's diet could reasonably avoid psychoactive levels of alcohol, but that's not strictly teetotalism.

The name[edit]

The name "teetotalism" has nothing to do with drinking tea instead of alcohol, or with playing golf (which would at least be the correct spelling). It stems from the notion of "Total abstinence, with a capital T" as opposed to other contemporary forms of temperance which forbade spirits but allowed for the consumption of beer and wine.[4]

Religion[edit]

More people are driven insane through religious hysteria than by drinking alcohol.
—W. C. Fields

Teetotalism is the official dogma of many religious sects, mostly fundamentalist ones, including Mormonism, Islam, and many Baptist and Pentecostal Christians, which says a lot about the nature of teetotalism. It is also the doctrine of many approaches to recovery from alcoholism such as that of Alcoholics Anonymous who teach that once a person is an alcoholic they are an alcoholic for life, and drinking even a drop will cause them to relapse.

Health[edit]

Some studies have shown that alcohol is actually good for your health, and therefore being teetotal must, by extension, be bad for you.[5] It has been shown with general health and obesity and has been attributed to social factors and antioxidants. Of course, it's only good for you in moderation, but is this really the case?

It has been postulated that these studies may show alcohol is "good" for you because the experiments are not properly controlled, that is, the two groups are not fully like-for-like. Teetotallers are a wide variety of individuals (not just those abstaining for religious reasons) and include recovering alcoholics as well as those who can't drink for health reasons (this is particularly true of those who are absolute in their avoidance of drink, rather than just disliking alcohol). This effect would skew the health of the teetotal "control" groups and give a false impression that drinking in moderation may be good for you.[6]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. Note: not drinking a drop of liquor is a perfectly honourable personal choice, if it means dipping your fingertip into your drink and flicking one drop away from you before you drink the rest.
  2. Ethanol content of various foods and soft drinks and their potential for interference with a breath-alcohol test by B. K. Logan & S. Distefano J. Anal. Toxicol. 1998 May-Jun;22(3):181-3.
  3. Nijssen, L. M., et al., eds. Volatile Compounds in Foods. Qualitative and Quantitative Data. 7th ed. Zeist, The Netherlands: TNO-CIVO Food Analysis Institute, 1996.
  4. http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition/
  5. Jonah Lehrer. Why Alcohol Is Good for You. Wired.com. 2010 September 7. Note: Jonah Lehrer's own publisher, Wired, considers his work to fail to uphold their editorial standards. So take what he writes with a big grain of salt.
  6. Ben Goldacre. Trivial Disputes. Bad Science. 2005 December 17.