There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff – we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.
If everyone who saw this today donated $5, we would meet our goal for 2019.
| Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.|
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with !
| Against allopathy|
GreenMedInfo.com is a website operated by Sayer Ji which opposes vaccination, hates GMOs, is vehemently anti-fluoride and promotes a wide range of assorted cancer woo.
Probably the truest statement on the website is the disclaimer at the bottom: "This article is not intended to provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment."
The GMI website was founded in 2008 "in order to provide the world an open access, evidence-based resource supporting natural and integrative modalities", and appears to be a popular one. In July 2016, GMI's Facebook page had 390,000 likes (compare to crank mothership NaturalNews, which boasts 1,900,000 likes). The website is ranked among the top 40 thousand by Alexa — still a significant amount of traffic.
GMI presents many natural products as equal to or superior to all "modern" medicines/chemicals. GMI also promotes numerous conspiracy theories about Big Pharma and GMO-producing companies, such as Monsanto.
Ji, the site's founder, generally despises "modern" medicine — referring to it as "cannibalism" — and further declaring that evidence-based medicine is "as reliable as a coin flip". Ji has also attacked Science Blogs and Respectful Insolence for pointing out his quackery.
GMI also opposes animal research, without which biomedical science would grind to a halt (for veterinary medicine and the ability to treat sick animals, as well as for general medicine). GMI also takes gluten woo to new levels, alleging that eating wheat now causes schizophrenia.
200 Evidence-Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate
Perhaps GMI's worst example of fact-distortion and use of medical babble is their publication, 200 Evidence-Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate, widely spread around the Internet. In typical Gish Gallop form, each of the 200 "reasons" is just the citation information of a single scientific study — GMI doesn't even bother to explain why each citation proves vaccines are bad.
When the studies are actually investigated, however, all of the studies either:
- Prove vaccination is not the cause of the problem
- Note that the studies are small and weak, or come from extremely questionable researchers (like the Geier family)
The publication seems impressive only because it is long — and seems designed to overwhelm casual readers into thinking that a large scientific literature attacking vaccinations exists.
“”The science of psychiatry is [a] myth.
GMI posts articles from one of their lead contributors, Kelly Brogan, whom they describe as:
…boarded in Psychiatry/Psychosomatic Medicine/Reproductive Psychiatry and Integrative Holistic medicine, and practices Functional Medicine, a root-cause approach to illness as a manifestation of multiple-interrelated systems.
Which is a way of saying "crank quack" that just takes forever.
Brogan is a zealous proponent of the anti-psychiatry movement, arguing — among other things — for the importance of not proactively aiding potential school shooters with sorely needed medication.
GMI's articles follow a formula: GMI finds a recent scientific publication, summarizes it for a few paragraphs, and tacks on several paragraphs that are only tangentially related to the article about how it proves [X alternative medicine is correct] and/or [modern medicine is a sham]. Not only does this lend credibility to his writing, it also makes his job easier — he doesn't need to come up with new content, just repeat work other people have done.
For example, in "New Study Links GMO Food To Leukemia", Ji begins with a summary of the study:
Now, a new study published in the Journal of Hematology & Thromboembolic Diseases indicates that the biopesticides engineered into GM crops known as Bacillus Thuringensis (Bt) or Cry-toxins, may also contribute to blood abnormalities from anemia to hematological malignancies (blood cancers) such as leukemia.
Ji continues with a brief history of Bt toxins and lists the four most extreme conclusions of the study. He then concludes that -- suprise suprise -- this means that GMOs are evil and should be banned:
The reality is that we no longer have time to wait around for additional research to accumulate on the adverse health effects of GMOs, especially considering the biotech industry has far more capital to infuse into their own faux research on the topic.
Some, in fact, argue that we should not be waiting around for the corrupt legislative process to compel manufacturers to label GMOs, rather, we should be fighting to ban them altogether, advocating for the precautionary principle before it is too late to undo the damage to our biosphere.
In the meantime, you can join the growing movement to March Against Monsanto, occurring world wide on May 25th, as a way of expressing your desire for real change, as well as vote with your forks, the only immediately effective tool we have against biological and environmental harms caused by the dominant GMO-based food system.
The strangest thing about the rush by [GMI and the Organic Consumers Association] and other anti-GMO folks to call this the latest “GMO” scandal is that the study didn’t test Bt toxins expressed by biotech crops. It didn't even test the Bt toxins expressed in bacteria then purified. Instead, the paper says they used "spore-crystals Cry1Aa, Cry1Ab, Cry1Ac and Cry2Aa from B. thuringiensis var. kurstaki were obtained in lyophilized form". Some B. thuringiensis bacteria can go dormant, forming a spore, and form crystals around the outside of the bacteria to protect themselves.
In other words, this study used the whole bacteria – the exact same thing that is used in organic Bt sprays. According to Organic Consumers Association, Bt sprays are used by "at least 57 percent of organic farmers" and "does not have detrimental effects on mammals, birds or non-target insect species and microorganisms. In addition, Bt sprays leave no poisonous residue on crops or trees and are readily degraded into the environment." Yet somehow [GMI and OCA think that] the exact same active ingredient, when expressed in a transgenic plant, lasts a long time in the environment and is now toxic to everything, according to OCA et al (despite the pesky science that says it doesn’t).
- Posts tagged Sayer Ji at Respectful Insolence
- Sayer Ji / GreenMedInfo has a URL called "cosmiconvergence.org".
- 200 Evidence-Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate — FREE Research PDF Download!, GreenMedInfo (see 200 Evidence-Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate)
- Beware of Organ Removal for "Cancer Prevention": Jolie's Precautionary Tale; response by Respectful Insolence
- Is BRCA ("Breast Cancer Gene") A Death Sentence?; response by Respectful Insolence
- "Did Angelina Jolie Make A Mistake By Acting On The 'Breast Cancer Gene' Theory?"; response by Science Based Medicine
- "Deconstructing '200 Evidence-Based Reasons NOT To Vaccinate'", Science-Based Medicine